Cone search interface data
Ray Plante
rplante at ncsa.uiuc.edu
Tue Dec 14 00:29:53 PST 2004
Hey Matthew,
I too would like to see our cone search resources as well as our SIAs more
fully described. With the NCSA registry, we intended to have the
registry fill in the extra information about parameters automatically for
the registrant when the service is registered.
In the case of Cone Search, the spec is ambiguous as to whether parameters
other than RA, DEC, SR, and VERB are allowed/meaningful. At the very
least, however, a registry could fill in the description of the required
parameters (RA, DEC, & SR).
For SIA, the spec explicitly indicates that the support for input
parameters should be described in the VOTable that is returned in response
to a "metadata" query (FORMAT=METADATA). Thus, when an SIA is registered,
the registry could automatically do a metadata query and fill in the
parameter information into the resource description.
By making this information optional, we do not over-burden either the
registrant or the registry with having to provide this info from the
get-go. The description is still useful (as DataScope demonstrates)
because as standard services, we know what minimum parameters they must
support (and that they will ignore parameters they don't support).
Of course, if you don't provide this info for non-standard services, the
description is essentially useless--caveat emptor. The NCSA registration
portal does provide the necessary interface to enter this (as I'm sure
Carnivore does as well).
cheers,
Ray
More information about the registry
mailing list