Facility and instrument terms in the different protocols
Tamara Civera
tcivera at cefca.es
Wed Apr 27 18:57:23 CEST 2022
Dear DAL, Registry,
I am writing to you due to the definitions of the terms/fields
"facility" and "instrument" used in the different protocols Obscore,
SIAP v 2.0 and VoDataService. I have found that the current ones can
cause confusion, especially the "facility" term (I send attached a
"facility_name" list from different Observatories Obscore services and
in some, this field contains the observatory name, in other the
telescope name,...). So I propose to clarify and unify them in these
protocols.
Current "Facility" definition according to the different VO protocols
documentation:
* Obscore "Facility" definition:
o "B7.1 The Facility class codes information about the observatory
or facility used to collect the data."
o "C.3
<FIELDname="facility_name"datatype="char"ucd="meta.id;instr.tel"utype="obscore:Provenance.ObsConfig.Facility.name"xtype="adql:VARCHAR"arraysize="128*"><DESCRIPTION>telescope
name</DESCRIPTION></FIELD>"
* SIAP 2.0 "Facility" definition: "2.1.12 The FACILITY parameter is a
string-valued parameter that specifies the name of the facility
(usually telescope) where the data was acquired. The value is
compared with the facility_name from the ObsCore [7] data model"
* VoDataService "Facility" definition: "3.1.1 The observatory or
facility used to collect the data contained or managed by this
resource."
Current "Instrument" definition according to the different VO protocols
documentation:
* Obscore "Instrument" definition: "B7.2 The name of the instrument
used for the acquisition of the observation."
* SIAP 2.0 "Instrument" definition: "2.1.13 The INSTRUMENT parameter
is a string-valued parameter that specifies the name of the
instrument with which the data was acquired. The value is compared
with the instrument_name from the ObsCore [7] data model."
* VoDataService "Instrument" definition: "3.1.1 The instrument used to
collect the data contain or managed by a resource."
After discussing this topic with Markus Demleitner in the IVOA
Interoperability Meeting, we have thought these possible definitions for
facility and instrument:
"Facility" should contain the name of the device that collected the
messenger particles (as opposed to the detector, which is in
"instrument"). In the optical, this would usually designate a
telescope, in the radio, it would be a dish or an array, for space
missions, usually the whole probe.
"Instrument" should contain the name of the device used for analysing
and detecting the messenger particles. Instances of such devices would
include cameras, spectrographs, or particle detectors.
Thanks,
Tamara Civera
--
Tamara Civera Lorenzo
Scientific Database and Web Access Engineer
Logotipo CEFCA *Centro de Estudios de Física del Cosmos de Aragón*
* Plaza San Juan nº 1, piso 2º
* 44001 Teruel
* Tfno: +34978221266 - Ext: 1116
* Fax: +34978602334
* Email: tcivera at cefca.es <mailto:tcivera at cefca.es>
* Url: http://www.cefca.es <http://www.cefca.es>
Este correo electrónico y, en su caso, cualquier archivo adjunto al
mismo, contiene información de carácter confidencial exclusivamente
dirigida a su destinatario. Queda prohibida su divulgación, copia o
distribución a terceros sin la previa autorización escrita de nuestra
entidad. En el caso de haber recibido este correo electrónico por
error, por favor, elimínelo de inmediato y notifique esta circunstancia
al remitente. En conformidad con lo establecido en las normativas
vigentes de Protección de Datos a nivel nacional y europeo,
le informamos que en la Fundación CEFCA tenemos un interés legítimo para
tratar sus datos de contacto con la finalidad de informarle de nuestras
actividades y gestionar sus peticiones. Sus datos no serán cedidos
a terceros, y los conservaremos sólo mientras sea necesario para
el mantenimiento de nuestra relación o la gestión de su solicitud. Puede
ejercer sus derechos de acceso, rectificación y supresión de sus datos,
así como los derechos de limitación y oposición a su tratamiento con
fines promocionales, escribiendo a rgpd at cefca.es. También puede
dirigirse a nuestro Delegado de Protección de Datos para
cualquier consulta relacionada con nuestra política de
privacidad, escribiendo a dpd at cefca.es .
------------------------------------------------------------------------
This email and, when appropriate, any file attached to it, contains
confidential information exclusively addressed to its recipient. It is
forbidden the disclosure, copying or distribution of this email to third
parties without the prior written authorization of our entity. Should
you have received this email by mistake, please delete it immediately
and notify the sender of this circumstance. According to the provisions
of current Data Protection regulations at national and European level,
we inform you that at CEFCA we have a legitimate interest to process
your contact data in order to inform you of our activities and manage
your requests. Your data will not be transferred to third parties, and
we will keep it only as long as it is necessary for the maintenance of
our relationship or the management of your request. You can exercise
your rights of access, rectification and deletion of your data, as well
as the rights of limitation and opposition to its treatment for
promotional purposes, by writing to rgpd at cefca.es. You can also contact
our Data Protection Officer for any query related to our privacy policy,
writing to dpd at cefca.es .
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.ivoa.net/pipermail/dal/attachments/20220427/12c514a3/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: logo.png
Type: image/png
Size: 3470 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://mail.ivoa.net/pipermail/dal/attachments/20220427/12c514a3/attachment.png>
-------------- next part --------------
ACP->ASA N-8 Dark Ridge Observatory
ACP->TheSky Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory
ACP->TheSky Dark Ridge Observatory
ALMA
APEX-12m
ASKAP
Anglo-Australian Telescope (AAO-AAT)
Apache Point 1.0m
Apache Point 2.5m
BETA
BLAST
Byurakan Astrophysical Observatory BAO
CFHT 3.6m
CTIO-1.5m
DAO 1.2-m
DAO 1.8-m
DRAO-ST
ESO Schmidt
ESO-3.6
ESO-NTT
ESO-VISTA
ESO-VLT-U1
ESO-VLT-U1234
ESO-VLT-U2
ESO-VLT-U2,ESO-VLT-U3
ESO-VLT-U234
ESO-VLT-U3
ESO-VLT-U4
ESO-VLTI-A1234
ESO-VLTI-A124
ESO-VLTI-U1234
ESO-VST
EVLA
FCRAO
FUSE
Gemini-North
Gemini-South
HESS
HST
Hitomi
IRAS
JAO
JCMT
LOFAR
Liverpool Telescope
MOST
MPG/ESO-2.2
MULTI
Mt. Stromlo Observatory 50 inch
NEOSSat
NGTS
NRO45m
No Value
None
OAJ - JAST/T80
OAJ - JST/T250
OMM-1.6m
SDSS
SUBARU
Subaru Telescope
TESS
UK Schmidt Telescope (AAO-UKST)
UKIRT
UKST
VISTA
VLA
VLT
VSOP(HALCA)
WSRT
XMM-Newton
gscp8m
palomar Observatory
unknown
More information about the dal
mailing list